PlumberSurplus.com Ecommerce and Entrepreneurship Blog | About | Contact | PlumberSurplus.com Store

The User Experience: Do Current Shoppers Take Precedence Over New Visitors?

Posted on December 3, 2008 by Zach

While performing a little research I came across something which both amazed and shocked me. Apparently there is at least one internet retailer out there who can afford to turn away customers in an effort to provide a better user experience for those already on their website. It’s very red carpet. Like a bouncer in front of a gated entrance, with clipboard in hand referencing a list that you may or may not have gotten on.  I am talking about Macy's site governor (pictured below).  The feature keeps new visitors to the website at a temporary holding page until current users finish what they are doing and leave the website. Apparently they have some kind of user or performance based cap that kicks into effect to control the traffic and/or load time on their other pages. I am not sure if they simply don't have the capacity to handle all of the traffic they would normally receive or if there are other reasons to throttle users on their website but I found the solution both annoying and frustrating. If I was a “normal user” I would simply go to another website to find what I was looking for (who has time to wait around?). Since I was interested in this practice I held on to see when I would be let in. After waiting more than 10 minutes I was finally let in and forwarded to the normal Macy's homepage and was able to continue with normal use of the website.

While I am not sure what the reasons or results of such a feature on an eCommerce website might be, I also can't imagine what it might do for their bottom line and conversion rate. I started thinking about it, but was unable to test if the feature restricts visitors to non homepage pages, users from paid marketing channels, organic traffic or just direct traffic like myself? Regardless, it’s hard for me to grasp why an eCommerce website would enable a feature which deliberately turns away shoppers?  Comments are welcomed and encouraged, I would love to hear what others have to say about the subject.

Macy's Site Governor

 

 

Digg It!DZone It!StumbleUponTechnoratiRedditDel.icio.usNewsVineFurlBlinkListFacebookTwitter

Comments

December 3. 2008 05:15

It's not rare. I can turndown anyone if i am the website's owner to achieve an efficient and targeted costumer.

charles

December 3. 2008 07:12

Lol, that is hilarious.

Hmm, if they'd only spent as much time working on server capacity as they did designing and writing this page, maybe this wouldn't be an issue.

Justin Palmer

December 3. 2008 07:16

Wow! Since I can't imagine this being a technological issue (virtualization, servers, etc. are relatively cheap), this has to be a marketing ploy!? I think!

Russ

December 3. 2008 08:46

Simply put, a company as large as Macy's should be able to hold a large capacity of individuals despite returning customer or first time buyer. Their fault for not helping their new customers.

Me

December 3. 2008 08:56

Thanks for the comments everyone.

@ Justin, Russ, and Me
Yea I would hope a company that large (far larger than we are) would be able to support the load for their website. I can't imagine they are getting so much traffic they can't handle it, maybe they are great at getting on the front page of digg haha.

@ charles
I certainly understand that the control is available and restrictions could be put in place by channel, refer information or other means but would it really make that much of a difference? It seems like whatever sales or traffic could be had via those channels that the sales (even if they are few) would be worth providing the extra capacity.

Zach

December 3. 2008 10:56

Do you think it could be their way of saying, as you pointed out, that their website is unable to handle the traffic they were experiencing? Do you think they are saying it in a way they believe is still polite and welcoming, but didn't think it through from the average web user's mind? It seems like when they say "new visitor" they mean "next in line." I don't know, but I agree that a site with that much visibility should be able to take on more traffic. I think the same about Universities/Colleges that use websites for registration, but don't seem to be able to back up their servers for the amount of students who need to register at the time they were allotted (wink, wink).

Casey

December 4. 2008 03:17

@ Casey

Yea that's what I assume, my problem with that is there are many ways to deal with more web traffic and I can't imagine that the sales they would get from letting everyone in would not warrant the added resources. Computers, hardware, software and services are to a point now days where its relatively cheap to add capacity.

Zach

December 5. 2008 07:45

Don't I know it, which makes it all that more absurd that companies and others still don't invest in growing their online services. Although, some companies may prefer you to go to their stores in order to have an easier upsell opportunity. Maybe Macy's wants people to think that it would be easier to just go shopping the old fashioned way. Don't they know that most people who shop online are doing so, because they want the ease and convenience of not having to fight the crowds?

Casey

December 5. 2008 12:21

Wow!  That's simply unexcusible!  I stumbled upon another one that was almost as shocking tonight.  DelightfulDeliveries - who sells Gift Baskets - has a big red box right on the home page that says, "Happy Holidays.  We are currently closed for renovations and will re-open by Dec. 11th.  Sincerely, DelightfulDeliveries.com".  

They are an IR 500 retailer.  Selling Gift Baskets.  In December.  Wow.

Corbin

December 10. 2008 02:15

Perhaps its better than simply having the whole site crash when close to capacity, but there's no way I'd wait in line. No excuse for this from such a big company.

Graham

Comments are closed